Need help booking? Call us at 1-800-293-2602
US$
$£€
Hotels' Currency
AR$
Argentine Pesos
AU$
Australian Dollars
R$
Brazilian Reals
£
British Pounds Sterling
CA$
Canadian Dollars
CN¥
Chinese Yuan
Kč
Czech Republic Korunas
Dkr
Danish Kroner
€
Euros
HK$
Hong Kong Dollars
Rs
Indian Rupees
Rp
Indonesian Rupiah
₪
Israeli New Sheqels
JP¥
Japanese Yen
RM
Malaysian Ringgit
MX$
Mexican Pesos
MAD
Moroccan Dirham
NZ$
New Zealand Dollars
Nkr
Norwegian Kroner
₱
Philippine Peso
zł
Polish Zloty
руб.
Russian Rubles
S$
Singapore Dollars
R
South African Rand
₩
South Korean Won
Skr
Swedish Kronor
₣
Swiss Francs
NT$
Taiwan New Dollar
฿
Thai Baht
TL
Turkish Lira
Dh
UAE Dirhams
$
US Dollars
₫
Vietnamese Dong
Reservations
Create an Account
Sign In
Forgot Password?
Remember me
Sign in with Email
Sign in with Okta
Toggle navigation
Destination
Check In
Check Out
Update Search
Search Results
Displaying
80 Hotels near Shelter Island Heights, NY
Sort
results
by:
Best Sellers
Guest Rating
Star Rating
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island Heights
4.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
0.8 miles from city center
Select this property
Sound View Greenport
Greenport
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
2.1 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Harborfront Inn at Greenport
Greenport
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
2.3 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Historic White Blossom House
Southold
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
3.2 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Baron's Cove
Sag Harbor
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Good
4.0 stars
based on 412 reviews
6.2 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Bridgehampton Inn
Sag Harbor
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
10.0 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
EHP Resort
East Hampton
3.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
11.4 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Capri Southampton
Southampton
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 96 reviews
11.8 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Harpoon House
Southampton
3.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
12.6 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
The Atlantic Hotel
Southampton
3.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 14 reviews
12.8 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Southampton Inn
Southampton
3.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 364 reviews
12.9 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Sea Haven Resort Motel
Southampton
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 7 reviews
13.2 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Hamlet Inn
Southampton
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
13.4 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
Old Saybrook
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
14.8 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Water's Edge Resort & Spa
Westbrook
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 1111 reviews
14.9 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Waters Edge Resort and Spa TimeShare
Westbrook
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
14.9 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook - Westbrook
Old Saybrook
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 136 reviews
15.1 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook
Old Saybrook
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 362 reviews
15.3 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
The Drake Inn
Hampton Bays
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
16.5 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Liberty Inn Old Saybrook
Old Saybrook
2.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 101 reviews
16.8 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Quality Inn Old Saybrook
Old Saybrook
2.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Okay
3.5 stars
based on 381 reviews
17.2 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
The Old Lyme Inn
Old Lyme
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Good
4.0 stars
based on 215 reviews
17.8 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Hyatt Place Long Island East End
Riverhead
3.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Good
4.5 stars
based on 1577 reviews
18.0 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
The Preston House and Hotel
Riverhead
3.5 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
18.0 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Scranton Seahorse Inn
Madison
3.0 Stars
To see our rates, please choose your check-in and check-out dates.
Choose dates
Good
4.5 stars
based on 341 reviews
18.4 miles from Shelter Island Heights, NY city center
Select this property
Home
Reservations
Sign in
Contact
1
Privacy Policy
Do Not Sell or Share My Information
Terms
$£€ - Hotels' Currency
AR$ - Argentine Pesos
AU$ - Australian Dollars
R$ - Brazilian Reals
£ - British Pounds Sterling
CA$ - Canadian Dollars
CN¥ - Chinese Yuan
Kč - Czech Republic Korunas
Dkr - Danish Kroner
€ - Euros
HK$ - Hong Kong Dollars
Rs - Indian Rupees
Rp - Indonesian Rupiah
₪ - Israeli New Sheqels
JP¥ - Japanese Yen
RM - Malaysian Ringgit
MX$ - Mexican Pesos
د.م. - Moroccan Dirham
NZ$ - New Zealand Dollars
Nkr - Norwegian Kroner
₱ - Philippine Peso
zł - Polish Zloty
руб. - Russian Rubles
S$ - Singapore Dollars
R - South African Rand
₩ - South Korean Won
Skr - Swedish Kronor
₣ - Swiss Francs
NT$ - Taiwan New Dollar
฿ - Thai Baht
TL - Turkish Lira
Dh - UAE Dirhams
US$ - US Dollars
VND - Vietnamese Dong